How many satchel charges for a sheet metal door

Both the sheet metal door and sheet metal double door require 4 satchel charges to be destroyed. ARMOURED DOOR Both the armoured door and armoured …

How many satchel charges for a sheet metal door. To destroy Metal Sheet Doors in Rust, you need at least four Satchels per Metal door. The following resources are everything you need to make four Satchels: Components and Refined items: 16 Beancan Grenades. Four Stashes. 960 Gun Powder. Four Rope. Raw Resources: 320 Metal Fragments.

Door, the cheaper is satchels but if the guy is online he can repair door, c4 is better for armored door, rockets is good for honeycomb. 1 c4 or 1 rocket 1 bean can or 4 sachels. The most sulfur-effecient way of raiding a sheet metal door is having a lot of bones (you'll need around 15 bone clubs) + 1 rocket.

how many rockets for sheet metal wall 2022 rust. by | Nov 5, 2022 | royal navy ships 1890 | diy spider repellent indoor | Nov 5, 2022 | royal navy ships 1890 | diy spider repellent indoorit is FOUR satchel charges to break a sheet metal door, right? 4 is correct. Or 63 explo ammo. Or 1 rocket and 8 explo ammo. That link I posted has all that info in it. If they do, I'd need 12 total for the 2 doors + the sheet metal door to actually reach the tc. Correct. then if they DIDN'T have a double door I'd be wasting 2 satchelsRecommended Read: How Many C4 to Destroy Wood, Stone, and Sheet Metal Walls in Rust? In general, the best explosives throughout a Rust playthrough are the satchel charges, rockets, and timed explosive charges (C4). So, in this guide, we will tell you exactly how many satchels, rockets, and C4 you will need to use to destroy armored walls in Rust.Introduction to Raiding Quick Sheet. This guide is designed to be easy-to read and access, feel free to either open this guide whilst in-game during a raid to quickly see cheapest raiding methods or if you run out of the main explosives, finding a method with the resources you currently have available. IMPORTANT: In each of the cheapest raid ...A single C4 charge will deal 275 damage to the armored wall. With 2k HP, you will need 8 C4 charges to destroy an armored wall in Rust. To make 8 C4 charges, you will need 17.6k sulfur. This means that the C4 charges are the least expensive if you consider your need to destroy armored walls. You can also use only 7 C4 charges to damage the wall ...

About to do my first raid ever! I'll be raiding a 2 sheet metal door base (8 satchels) that I've had my eyes on for a while. Any tips on what IThe Explosive Charge (commonly called "C4" or "Satchel Charge") is a craftable explosive weapon that can be placed on walls and doors. ... 2-3 Explosive Charges Metal Door : 2-3 Explosive Charges Metal Wall : 3-4 Explosive Charges Wood Doorway: 2-3 Explosive Charges metal bars: 2-4 Legacy Items. Ammo. 556 Ammo • 9mm Ammo • Arrow ...how many do you need to raid a garage metal door ? and a metal sheet door? other forums seems too old and don't know if any patches fixed themIf you're looking to install a 3 sheet metal door, you'll need at least 3 satchels of screws. Each sheet should have 4 screws at the top and bottom, so a total of 12 screws will be needed. ... If you're looking to blow up a garage door, you'll need at least two C4 charges and one satchel charge. This will vary depending on the size of ...it is FOUR satchel charges to break a sheet metal door, right? 4 is correct. Or 63 explo ammo. Or 1 rocket and 8 explo ammo. That link I posted has all that info in it. If they do, I'd need 12 total for the 2 doors + the sheet metal door to actually reach the tc. Correct. then if they DIDN'T have a double door I'd be wasting 2 satchelsIIRC, this causes a lot of damage to the gun though. satchels are probably the most commonly used item to blow sheet metal doors. Bone hammer raids ftw. Tbh it would probably be cheaper and faster to build a new base. 24 Salvaged Hammers. 1 rocket and 8 xplo. Rock would be the cheapest way to go.

The Test of Time: Durability of Sheet Metal Walls. Sheet metal walls are known for their toughness. They can withstand: 200 hits from a rock; 23 hits from a pickaxe; 7 satchel charges; 2 C4 charges; The lifespan of a sheet metal wall is significantly affected by its exposure to damage and the maintenance it receives. Winning Strategies for ...A single C4 charge will deal 440 damage to the armored door. So, you will deal almost half the health of the door with a single charge. So this means that you will need 3 C4 charges to destroy an armored door in Rust. To make 3 C4 charges, you will need 6.6k sulfur. Though C4 charges are more expensive than rockets, they get the job done faster.I didn't consider throwing satchel charges or c4 an option for destroying auto turrets. You'd need to be very close to land them. ... in 20 sheet metal doors you would have 20 spare bullets (the one remainder each door) which would yield enough to go through a 21st door. However, the 1k sulfur you save allows you to make nearly 17 more surveys ...The Satchel Charge is a craftable explosive that can be thrown on Towers, Doors and Deployable items. Once a Satchel Charge has been stuck to an object it will automatically arm itself. ... Useful for destroying wood and sheet metal doors General Shortname: Satchel Charge Type: Explosive Stack Size: 10 Weapon Stats Crafting Craftable: Yes Time ...Yes, but it may take more satchel charges to destroy a sheet metal door compared to explosive ammo. See 3,000+ New Gun Deals HERE. 6. Are there any tools or weapons ...Top More 9 How Many Satchel Charges To Blow A Door Must Read HOW TO BREAK A SHEET METAL DOOR IN RUST - YouTube Steam Community :: Guide :: Rust: Satchel Charges Raid Costs - Cheat Sheet [AUGUST 2023]

Lifespa northbrook.

Yes, other weapons such as satchel charges or rocket launchers can also be used to destroy sheet metal doors. How long does it take to destroy a sheet metal door with explosive ammo? It takes approximately 4 minutes to destroy a sheet metal door using explosive ammo.Door, the cheaper is satchels but if the guy is online he can repair door, c4 is better for armored door, rockets is good for honeycomb. 1 c4 or 1 rocket 1 bean can or 4 sachels. The most sulfur-effecient way of raiding a sheet metal door is having a lot of bones (you'll need around 15 bone clubs) + 1 rocket.Satchel Charge: Short Name: explosive.satchel: ItemID-1878475007: Item Description: Small explosive package constructed of beancan grenades. Useful for destroying wood and sheet metal doors. Default Stacksize: 10Metal Doorway. The Metal Doorway is the direct upgrade from its precursor, the stone doorway. Doorways can be used to hold wood, sheet metal, and armoured doors, as well as vending machines. Because sheet metal doors require half the explosives to break as a stone doorway, metal doorways are typically used only when paired with an armoured door ...Rust - How Many Satchels to Destroy Doors: Wood, Garage, and Sheet Metal - Gamer Empire RUST Satchel Charge Skins, Crafting Data, and Insights - Corrosion Hour Steam Community :: Guide :: Destoying Sheet Metal DoorsThey are much easier to find for blueprints than rockets and C4. They can be used to blow down doors and breach enemy bases via the weak spots. Satchel Charge details: It takes 12 satchels to destroy an armored door. It takes 46 satchels to destroy an armored wall. Satchels do 43.5 damage to the strongest items/materials in the game. …

shell helix hx5 15w-40 data sheet. waste management organizations. Menu halo infinite players; anger leads to hate hate leads to suffering; john b wells ark midnight live; my priorities in life as a student essay; ... Geplaatst op 31/03/2022 door . rust how many satchels for wood door ...To destroy a metal wall in the game, it typically takes 2 explosive ammo rounds. See 3,000+ New Gun Deals HERE.peklo plastický mít důvěru rust how many satchel charge for metal doors Rada kolidovat Podepsat. Rust Raiding Economics - The wooden door - YouTube. Satchel charges, rotation, and a bunch more! — Rustafied. ... Tips Explaining How Many Satchels For A Sheet Metal Door? 09/2023.Useful for destroying wood and sheet metal doors. Small explosive package constructed of beancan grenades. Useful for destroying wood and sheet metal doors. Items . World . Articles; Tool . ru; Home; Items; Tool; nav.items.tool.explosive-satchel; Satchel Charge. explosive.satchel -1878475007. Small explosive package constructed of beancan ...Assault Rifle: 2.4dmg ( 417 rounds) LR-300 Assault Rifle: 2.4dmg ( 417 rounds) M249: 2.4dmg ( 417 rounds) Semi-Automatic Rifle: 2.4dmg ( 417 rounds) Notes: Explosive rounds inflict almost the same damage to the weak side as the strong side of walls at 1.05x, and can start fires, but the fire inflicts no damage to sheet metal walls.Small explosive package constructed of beancan grenades. Useful for destroying wood and sheet metal doors. Satchel charges have a chance to "dud" when thrown. Such satchels will not explose and instead require a player to interact with them. When this happens, the satchel is either placed back in the players inventory or reignites with a shorter fuse. You better get out of there ...Beancan Grenade. The Beancan Grenade is an early-game tool. They're used to craft Satchel Charges, but can be used by themselves in raiding. The Beancan Grenade has a random detonation period and can kill a player if it's within the range. The Beancan Grenade has a 15% chance to be a dud. However, Beancan Grenades have a 50% …Verified answer. Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like How many c4 does it take to destroy a wooden wall, How many c4 does it take to destroy a stone wall, How many c4 does it take to destroy a sheet metal wall and more.All items from the metal building tier require 23 satchel charges to be destroyed. These items include:walls, foundations, floors, doorframes, walls, stairs, rooves, wallframes, floorframes and windows. This does not include the sheetmetal door.How many satchels do I need for a stone wall? how many satchels for sheet metal wall.If you're flying between New York and Paris on Air France in the not-too-distant future, you could be in for a big upgrade. If you're flying between New York and Paris on Air Franc...Crafting one Satchel Charge requires: 4 Beancan Grenade. 1 Small Stash. 1 Rope. Takes about 30 seconds to craft a single Satchel Charge using the materials above. Raw farming materials required for crafting: 480 Sulfur to make Gun Powder. 720 Charcoal to make Gun Powder. 60 Metal Fragments to make Beancan Grenade.

how many satchel charges to blow up wooden and sheet metal doors ? 1 or 2 Wood 4 Metal 10 Armored. Rustlabs.com is a great source! 657K subscribers in the playrust community. The largest community for the game RUST.

Top More 9 How Many Satchel Charges To Blow A Door Must Read. Satchel charge raiding costs : r/playrust. Explosives Cost Chart : r/playrust. Raid cost guide : r/RustConsole. ... Sheet Metal Double Door • Rust Labs. RUST - Satchel Charge - Rust - Magnet | TeePublic.This is a more advanced guide which shows how many explosives are required to destroy a wood door! C4. It takes 1x C4 to break the wood door! 1x C4 = 0/200. Rocket. It takes 1x rockets to break the wood door! 1xRocket = 0/200. Satchel Charge. It takes 2x Satchel Charge to break a wood door!2 satchels for a wooden door and 4 for a sheet metal door. For a stone wall it's 11 so depending on the base I might consider doors. But if it had garage doors your cost goes up.The Sheet Metal Door is the most common door found on bases due to its resistances to melee weapons and fire but relatively cheap cost to craft. ... Satchel Charge: 4 ... The armored double door is the highest tier double door and is the best for base defense. Because of its high durability, if the door is placed in a weak wall frame, raiders may target the wall frame instead of the door itself. The door has working hatches and these hatches allow you to see outside of the door and can be shot through in both ... Published on: August 21, 2022. Written by Eric Devin / Fact-checked by David Rowan. In short, at least two satchel charges are essential for a garage door. This is because the weight of the garage door will likely cause the first charge to fail. You can use more charges if you want to be sure that the door is destroyed, but two should be enough.15. Cost to unlock. 12 XP. Stackable to. 10. Satchels required to break building parts: Wood door. 2. Sheet metal door. 4. Armored door. 12. Ladder hatch. 4. …

Grand summoners best crest for each unit.

2023 ruidoso select yearling sale.

How many for a sheet door or a stone wall etc, just curious if any info on damage was out ... Satchel Charge DMG? How many for a sheet door or a stone wall etc, just curious if any info on damage was out ... xJayPop. Aug 5, 2016 @ 3:01pm think its like 4 per sheet metal door, bit op tbh lol #1. Ryle. Aug 5, 2016 @ 7:23pm Go check out http ...It takes 4 satchels to take down a sheet metal door. Alternatively, you could upgrade to a garage door that has no weak side to explosives. So how many satchels do you need for the garage door? It takes 9 satchel charges to destroy the garage door. How many stone Spears does it take to soft side a stone wall? 23 spears for soft side so x10 is ...For double garage doors, a minimum of three satchels is advisable. One bag should be placed on either side, with the third satchel in the middle. The additional satchel strengthens the overall security by preventing the garage door from being pried open in the center.It takes 4 satchels to take down a sheet metal door, you can decrease the cost a little bit by using 3 satchels and 3 beancan grenades but it's not really worth the time and risk of the grenades just blowing up immediately in your face. It takes 10 satchels to get through a stone wall/foundation. It takes 9 Satchel Charges, or 150 Explosive 5. ...The future of phones is solid blocks of glass and metal. One of the biggest hassles with smartphones is that they die. Phone owners are constantly scrambling to find cables and soc...Satchel charge added. A new, lower tier way of raiding has been added: The satchel charge. Made of 4 beancan grenades and a small stash, this explosive package is good for destroying wood and sheet metal doors. They take 30 seconds to craft, stack to 10, and are unlocked at level 15.Related: How to destroy a Sheet Metal Door in Rust (5 easy ways) 3. How To Use Satchel Charge To Destroy Stone Walls . ... You need only ten total Satchel Charges to demolish any Stone Wall. In addition, if the charges do not malfunction, you can expect the wall to be destroyed within 22 seconds.Jan 5, 2020 How much damage does one satchel charge cause? Dud Chance 20 %How many spears do you need for a sheet metal door? Satchel Charge Damage 475 Explosion Radius 4 m Explosion Delay 6-12 sec Updated on July 4, 2018. A list of the amount of damage each weapon inflicts on a sheet metal door. Sheet metal doors contain 150 metal fragments ...Using a pickaxe on a sheet metal door is incredibly time-consuming and not recommended. How much damage does each explosive ammo do to a sheet metal door? Each explosive ammo inflicts 149.2 damage to a sheet metal door. ….

F-1 Grenades vs. Satchel Charges I was doing the math on resources needed for each to break down one sheet metal door. It seems as though the Satchel Charge is more effective on resources than using F-1 Grenades.Sheet Door - 70 DMG out of 250 HP [4 Satchels to Destroy] ... Destroyed within 1 Satchel Charge. Garage Door - 70 DMG out of 600 HP [9 Satchel Charge] Floor Grill - 70 DMG out of 250 HP [4 Satchels to Destroy] Ladder Hatch - 70 DMG out of 250 HP [4 Satchels to Destroy] Metal Shop - 43.5 DMG out of 750 HP [18 Satchels to Destroy] …Jan 17, 2024 · It takes approximately 4 satchel charges to destroy a sheet metal double door in Rust. How much explosive ammo does it take to destroy an armored double door? It takes approximately 34 explosive ammo to destroy an armored double door in Rust. Average metal roof cost per square foot. Both the sheet metal door and sheet metal double door require 4 satchel charges to be destroyed. Approximately 85 roofing sheets are required to roof such a house, the price of each roofing sheet ranges from shs25,000 to about shs90,000 depending on the type and.—Information accurate as of: 5/10/21 Update Timed Explosive Charges are not to be confused with Explosives The Timed Explosive Charge (commonly referred to as "C4") is a craftable explosive weapon that can be thrown onto walls, doors, or deployable items. Once a Timed Explosive Charge has been thrown, it will automatically arm itself and then detonate after 10 seconds. Players caught in the ...Satchel Charge: 10: 22 sec-×4,800: Pump Shotgun. Handmade Shell. ×556: 16 min 55 sec-×2,780: Pump Shotgun. 12 Gauge Buckshot. ×477: 14 min 31 sec-×4,770: Pump Shotgun. ... make it sheet metal when you can . Report; 1. literally kane 1 pts. 2 years ago. To break walls with spears easier, get spears to 1 hit until it breaks and then craft ...Using a pickaxe on a sheet metal door is incredibly time-consuming and not recommended. How much damage does each explosive ammo do to a sheet metal door? Each explosive ammo inflicts 149.2 damage to a sheet metal door.A floor, made of metal. ... Tool Quantity Time Fuel Sulfur; MLRS Rocket: 6: 0 sec--40mm HE Grenade: 57: 1 min 12 secThis guide shows details of satchel raid's and what is needed for them. Short About Guide Here I'll show satchel raid's and what is needed for them. Doors Wooden door - 2 satchels. (960 sulfur/1440 coal).Iron door - 4 satchels. (1920 sulfur/2880 coal).HQM door - 12 satchels. (5760 sulfur/8640. How many satchel charges for a sheet metal door, Short Answer - 9 Satchels for garage door, 15 satchels for vending machine, 2 satchels for auto turret. If you liked the video, then consider subscribing.--M..., Sheet Metal Door. 63 Explosive Ammo: 1,575 Sulfur; 1 Rocket + 8 Explosive Ammo: 1,600 Sulfur; 4 Satchel Charges: 1,920 Sulfur; 1 C4: 2,200 Sulfur; Garage Door, Double sheet metal door: 7 satchels. A double sheet metal door is a more durable version of the single sheet metal door. It is made with two layers of sheet metal, which makes it more difficult to blow open. As a result, it requires more satchels to blow open than a single sheet metal door., Satchel Charge: 10: 22 sec-×4,800: Pump Shotgun. Handmade Shell. ×556: 16 min 55 sec-×2,780: Pump Shotgun. 12 Gauge Buckshot. ×477: 14 min 31 sec-×4,770: Pump Shotgun. ... make it sheet metal when you can . Report; 1. literally kane 1 pts. 2 years ago. To break walls with spears easier, get spears to 1 hit until it breaks and then craft ..., Wooden Door: Wooden doors are the weakest in terms of durability. They can be breached with 18 explosive rounds or other low-tier raiding tools. Sheet Metal Door: Sheet metal doors offer more protection compared to wooden ones. Depending on the situation, breaching a sheet metal door usually requires around 63 explosive rounds., The Test of Time: Durability of Sheet Metal Walls. Sheet metal walls are known for their toughness. They can withstand: 200 hits from a rock; 23 hits from a pickaxe; 7 satchel charges; 2 C4 charges; The lifespan of a sheet metal wall is significantly affected by its exposure to damage and the maintenance it receives. Winning Strategies for ..., 7 May 2023 ... Thanks for watching, and as always, have fun guys! TWITCH - http://www.twitch.tv/maxmears TWITTER - https://twitter.com/MaxMearsYT PATREON ..., 1 boneclub can do roughly 2 damage. 3 people with boneclubs on a sheet metal door and you can save lots of gunpowder since bones are useless. 2500 stone, also 1 rocket, 1 beancan and some rocks do the trick. absolute cheapest: 1 rocket + 2 Beancan grenades + 20~ hits with metal hatchet. 3 hits with mace ;), A rocket will deal around 137 damage. This means that you will need 8 rockets to completely destroy a sheet metal door in Rust. However, with only 7 rockets, the door will be left with around 40 HP. If you don't want to waste resources, you can finish the destruction with a satchel charge. Unfortunately, sheet metal walls are extremely ..., it is FOUR satchel charges to break a sheet metal door, right? 4 is correct. Or 63 explo ammo. Or 1 rocket and 8 explo ammo. That link I posted has all that info in it. If they do, I'd need 12 total for the 2 doors + the sheet metal door to actually reach the tc. Correct. then if they DIDN'T have a double door I'd be wasting 2 satchels , A general rule of thumb is to use one satchel per square foot of door surface. So, if you have a 4×8 foot metal door, you'll need 32 satchels. Of course, this is just a guideline. ... If you're looking to blow through a sheet metal door with C4 charges, you'll need at least two satchels worth of explosives. However, depending on the ..., Sheet music is the format in which songs are written down. Sheet music begins with blank music staff paper consisting of graphs that have five lines and four spaces, each of which ..., How Many Satchels for Sheet Metal Door 4. Credit: www.reddit.com . How Many C4 And Satchels Do I Need for a Sheet Metal Door? If you’re looking to blow through a sheet metal door, you’ll need at least two C4 charges and one satchel charge. More specifically, it will take two C4 charges placed on either side of the door, along …, Satchel charge raiding costs. So correct me if i'm wrong but I think I have done the math for the cheapest amounts of gunpowder for raiding doors. for wood your cheapest option would be 1 satchel charge and 1 beancan grenade. For sheetmetal your cheapest option would be 3 satchel charges and 2 bean cans (or just use 1 f1 grenade for reliabilaty), Corrugated sheet metal panels are a versatile and durable option for a wide range of applications. From roofing to siding, these panels provide excellent protection against the ele..., When it comes to finding the right sheet metal supplier for your project, it can be difficult to know where to start. With so many options available, it can be hard to narrow down ..., how many satchels for sheet metal doorbrown bug with black spots on back. april 10, 2022 / Posted By : / skateboarding terms shredding / Under : ..., The main tools that can be used for this purpose include the fuel satchel charge, F1 grenade, rocket, and timed explosive charge. Each of these tools has it's own quantity and effectiveness when it comes to demolishing the chain link fence. Starting off, the fuel satchel charge is a handy tool that can be used to break through a chain link fence., how many satchels for sheet metal doorpanera coffee traveler. Posted By : / oostende vs kortrijk virtual / Under : ..., Doors will be cheaper than blowing up walls, especially when the doors lack quality. On rare occasions, such as during online raids, lobbing rockets at the broadside of a structure isn't just warranted; it might be necessary. ... Satchel Charge. 3 Satchel Charges will get the job done, but always ensure that the base doesn't have Wood doors ..., 15. Cost to unlock. 12 XP. Stackable to. 10. Satchels required to break building parts: Wood door. 2. Sheet metal door. 4. Armored door. 12. Ladder hatch. 4. …, It takes 4 satchels to take down a sheet metal door, you can decrease the cost a little bit by using 3 satchels and 3 beancan grenades but it's not really worth the time and risk of the grenades just blowing up immediately in your face. It takes 10 satchels to get through a stone wall/foundation. It takes 9 Satchel Charges, or 150 Explosive 5. ..., Garage doors cost nine satchels or two c4 to blow down. A list of how much damage each weapon inflicts against a sheet metal door. A 150 explosive 5.56 rifle ammo is equivalent to 9 satchel charges that can also rust the door. It's not that much worse than an armoured door, and that costs 20 hqm and 5 gears., It requires nine satchel charges to destroy a garage door. How many satchel charges for an armored door? The armored door is strong. You will need high explosive power. It requires twelve satchel charges to destroy an armored door completely. How many satchel charges for a sheet metal door? A sheet metal door …, It takes 4 satchels to take down a sheet metal door, you can decrease the cost a little bit by using 3 satchels and 3 beancan grenades but it's not really worth the time and risk of the grenades just blowing up immediately in your face. It takes 10 satchels to get through a stone wall/foundation. It takes 9 Satchel Charges, or 150 Explosive 5. ..., It takes 9 Satchel Charges, or 150 Explosive 5.56 Rifle Ammo, to destroy the garage door and has no weak side (like other doors) to explosives. How do you remove rust from a garage door? Remove doors in RUST using a building hammer You can easily remove doors you own if it is wooden/sheet metal/armored, single, or double., February 27, 2023. 55 Views. 0. All items from the metal building tier require 23 satchel charges to be destroyed. These items include walls, foundations, floors, doorframes, walls, stairs, rooves, wall frames, floor frames, and windows. This does not include the sheet metal door., Satchel Charge: 15: 30 sec-×7,200: Explosive 5.56 Rifle Ammo. ... You can have plenty of armored doors deeper inside, but front it with a sheet metal door. Report; 1., #shorts #short #rust #rustclips, How much damage does an F1 grenade do to a sheet metal door. While F1 grenades may pack a punch, unfortunately, they won't be enough to demolish a sturdy sheet metal door. ... When it comes to metal doors, satchels aren't exactly door-busting material. A satchel charge will only deal a meager 150 damage to a metal door. You'll need ..., To destroy a sheet metal door or a sheet metal double door, you'll need four satchel charges. Like the double sheet metal door and ladder hatch, Sheet metal doors have the same hit points and defensive bonuses. Sheet metal doors have 250 hit points and 150 metal fragments. They are fireproof and resistant to hatchets but weaker than other ..., This guide will show you how many satchel charges it takes to destroy things in Rust. With Rust being constantly updated, there may be differences to Gun Damage, Explosive Damage, Item building/cr. Σύνδεση Κατάστημα ..., The satchel charge is a highly portable explosive that players can utilize to breach fortified structures, eliminate adversaries, or clear obstacles. It consists of a bag filled with explosives, a detonation mechanism, and shrapnel that disperses upon detonation. When it comes to breaching fortified structures, satchel charges have proven to be ...